Fantasy Baseball Guide for 2025 📈

Our comprehensive guide to playing fantasy baseball for the 2025 season.

Author

Ryan Finkelstein
March 19, 2025

In partnership with

As the MLB season fully kicks off next week, many are preparing for their own team’s season ahead…in the realm of fantasy baseball.

Build your fantasy dynasty with our expert positional rankings, draft strategies, and player insights.

We'd suggest bookmarking this bad boy and using it as your go-to checklist for the 2025 fantasy baseball season.

Dominate Your 2025 Fantasy League with Just Baseball's Expert Insights

Alright, pretend you're Billy Beane in Moneyball.

You know the key to winning your fantasy baseball league is preparation and in-depth research.

A solid draft strategy is important. You need to understand the most accurate player rankings and advanced insights so you can separate yourself from the competition.

You need a plan, a back-up plan, and a back-up plan to your back-up plan.

Whether you're in a standard 5x5 league, dynasty, or points league, this Fantasy Baseball Draft Guide 2025 has everything you need to make the smartest picks and decisions heading into draft day.

Here, we cover:

  • Position Rankings – The best players to draft at each position.

  • Draft Strategies – How to construct a balanced team.

  • Sleepers & Breakouts – Hidden gems that could win you your league.

  • Mock Drafts & ADP Trends – Insights into player values and market movement

Position Rankings for 2025

Stay ahead of the game with our in-depth position rankings. Click each position to view the full breakdown:

Each ranking includes expert analysis, key stats, and draft targets at every tier!

Mock Drafts & ADP Analysis

Understanding Average Draft Position (ADP) helps you draft smarter. Our mock drafts and ADP trends provide insights into player values and potential draft steals.

Read our full Fantasy Baseball Mock Draft Analysis to refine your draft plan.

Receive Honest News Today

Join over 4 million Americans who start their day with 1440 – your daily digest for unbiased, fact-centric news. From politics to sports, we cover it all by analyzing over 100 sources. Our concise, 5-minute read lands in your inbox each morning at no cost. Experience news without the noise; let 1440 help you make up your own mind. Sign up now and invite your friends and family to be part of the informed.

Draft Strategies & Expert Advice

A strong draft is the foundation of a championship team. Follow these expert strategies:

  • Early-Round Picks: Lock in elite talent while avoiding potential busts

  • Mid-Round Value: Find players who outperform their draft position

  • Late-Round Sleepers: Uncover hidden gems who could break out in 2025

  • Balancing Risk & Upside: How to take calculated risks on high-ceiling players

  • Best Fantasy Team Names (Puns): "Acuña Matata", "Bichette Happens" "Pitch, Please" -- stand out with a good team name (at least!)

Sleepers & Breakout Players

Every season, a few players exceed expectations and become league-winners. Our experts highlight this year’s top sleepers and breakout candidates:

Read More of our Breakout Players 2025 series for exclusive scoops on specific players, and get ahead of your competition.

FAQs About Fantasy Baseball

How does fantasy baseball points work?

Fantasy baseball scoring varies by league format. In points leagues, players earn points for positive stats like home runs, RBIs, runs, stolen bases, and strikeouts (for pitchers), while negative stats like strikeouts (for hitters) and earned runs (for pitchers) deduct points. In category-based leagues (Roto or H2H categories), teams compete across multiple statistical categories, with rankings determining points or wins.

What's the best way to start playing fantasy baseball?

To start playing fantasy baseball:

  1. Choose a platform (ESPN, Yahoo, CBS, Fantrax).

  2. Join a league or create your own (H2H, Roto, or Points format).

  3. Research rankings, draft strategies, and player trends.

  4. Participate in the draft, selecting players based on value and roster needs.

  5. Manage your team throughout the season with trades, waiver wire pickups, and lineup adjustments.

The most widely used fantasy baseball apps are:

  • ESPN Fantasy Baseball – User-friendly and widely popular.

  • Yahoo Fantasy Baseball – Great interface and customization.

  • CBS Fantasy Baseball – Premium features and deep analysis.

  • Fantrax – Highly customizable for dynasty and keeper leagues.

  • NFBC (National Fantasy Baseball Championship) – Best for high-stakes leagues.

What is the best position to draft first in fantasy baseball?

This depends on your league format, but typically, elite hitters (outfielders, shortstops, or first basemen) are prioritized in the first round. However, if there’s a top-tier ace available, drafting an elite pitcher early can also be a viable strategy.

In what order should I draft my fantasy team?

A general draft strategy follows this structure:

  1. Round 1-3: Elite hitters or an ace pitcher.

  2. Round 4-6: Balanced mix of power, speed, and strong pitching.

  3. Round 7-10: Fill positional needs and target value players.

  4. Round 11-15: High-upside players and late-round sleepers.

  5. Final Rounds: Backup depth, prospects, or specialists.

What is the weakest position in fantasy baseball?

Catcher is often considered the weakest position due to limited offensive production. Middle infield positions (second base and shortstop) can also be thin if you don’t draft a top-tier player early.

What is the strongest position in fantasy baseball?

Outfield and starting pitcher typically have the most depth, offering a wide range of elite, mid-tier, and sleeper options.

What's more important in fantasy baseball: pitching or hitting?

Hitting is generally more consistent, so many managers prioritize elite bats early. However, having strong pitching is crucial in points leagues and categories leagues where ratios (ERA, WHIP, K/9) matter. A balanced team is key to success.

Are catchers important in fantasy baseball?

While necessary for roster construction, catchers generally produce lower offensive stats than other positions. Unless you draft an elite catcher (like Adley Rutschman or Will Smith), waiting until later rounds for a serviceable option is a common strategy.

What is the most important stat in fantasy baseball?

This depends on league format, but some of the most valuable stats include:

  • Roto Leagues: Home runs, stolen bases, batting average, ERA, WHIP.

  • Points Leagues: OPS, total bases, strikeouts (for pitchers).

  • Category Leagues: Runs, RBIs, saves, K/9, OBP.

Who are the best sleeper picks in fantasy baseball for 2025?

Sleepers vary based on trends and breakouts, but some potential 2025 sleeper picks include:

  • Hitters: Bo Bichette, Cody Bellinger, Jurickson Profar, Isaac Paredes, Brandon Lowe, Ryan Mountcastle, Michael Conforto,

  • Pitchers: Clay Holmes, Cody Bradford, Matt Boyd, Spencer Strider

(Check our Fantasy Baseball Sleepers 2025 guide for a full breakdown.)

When should I draft pitchers in 2025?

While aces like Gerrit Cole and Paul Skenes will probably go early, many managers wait until Rounds 3-5 to grab their first starting pitcher. Depth allows for value picks later in the draft.

Who are the top 5 outfielders this year?

For 2025, the top fantasy outfielders include:

  1. Juan Soto. – Power & on-base machine, elite superstar

  2. Mookie Betts – Elite production across categories (and plays shortstop as well)

  3. Kyle Tucker– Elite outfielder, with Wrigley Field's wind

  4. Corbin Carroll – Young star looking to bounce back

  5. Aaron Judge – Power leader (when healthy)

Just Baseball Discord

We launched a Just Baseball community on Discord!

Our Discord channel is the ultimate baseball group chat while also providing exclusive access to Peter’s MLB best bets, Aram’s prospect content, giveaways, and direct connection to the entire Just Baseball staff.

Just Baseball Merch

Our newest line of merchandise features spring-theme apparel to get you ready for the upcoming MLB season!

We have also restocked all your favorites including our vintage World Series line, hats, hoodies, City Series line, and much more.